"Adl va Ensaf" Comparative Law Researches Quarterly

This publication is published electronically in the form of a quarterly journal in Persian with English abstract, It should be noted that respected researchers can take legal papers in all legal and interdisciplinary (law and other disciplines) such as: law economics, law politics, sociology of law, etc., provided that the comparative approach to the system Quarterly reports.Professors, researcher and students can submit their articles to the Quarterly electronic system, taking into account the writing style sheets of the articles in the Quarterly, so that after the review, if confirmed, they will be published at the time of publication of the Quarterly. Dear professors, researchers and students, you can find out about the process of accepting articles and related costs to the link:  

http://www.aeclrjournal.ir/journal/process.

Barriers to the Performance of the Obligation by a Third Party in the Afghanistan Legal System

https://doi.org/10.22034/aeclr.2024.485062.1153

Sayed Abbas Mosavi

Abstract According to Articles 806 and 898 and subsequent articles of the Afghanistan Civil Code, third parties can perform other's obligations. Two important legal effects have been arranged on this type of performance: the collapse of the debtor's obligation against the creditor and the creation of the right of recourse for a third party. Considering the acceptance of the third-party payment institution in the Afghanistan legal system and the effect of recourse on it, the purpose of this study is to investigate cases in which the third party is not competent to fulfill another obligation or has the right of recourse to him. In this research, using a descriptive-analytical type of qualitative research method and using the documentary method of data collection, we reach the conclusion that in cases where the obligor's personality is the main cause of the contract or the obligation is hidden to the person, the third party cannot perform the debtor's obligation without the consent of the creditor. Also, in the second paragraph of Article 898 of the Civil Code, the creditor has the authority to reject the performance of the obligation by a third party and in the second paragraph of Article 899 for the debtor, the authority to prevent the third party from returning to himself has been expressly accepted. Therefore, despite the acceptance of the institution of performance of the obligation by a third party in the legal system of Afghanistan, this legal institution has obstacles and exceptions that are examined in this study.

Justice; as fairness or human ability

https://doi.org/10.22034/aeclr.2024.486326.1154

Mohammadmehdi Rahimi

Abstract Since time immemorial, justice has been a very important concept and has been of interest to activists in the field of social sciences. This article tries to analyze the theory of John Rawls, a political philosopher of the 20th century, about justice and compare its content with the thought of Amartya Sen, a theorist and winner of the Nobel Prize in Economics (1998). ) to explain the new theory synthesized from the opinions of two philosophers. Therefore, by using the descriptive analytical method, the question has been raised that how is it possible to achieve justice based on fairness or ability? And by using the conceptual framework of justice of John Rawls and Amarthiasen, this hypothesis has been raised: Rawls and Sen views They are similar to utilitarianism, which sees its end in general welfare and happiness for the maximum society. But in their methodology, they are different and inconsistent regarding the realization of fair conditions. From Rawls' point of view, fairness is the principle of equality of fair opportunities, and from Amarthiasen's point of view, it means the existence of conditions that present different options for people to choose, and time selection means that a person has the right to choose between different options and will become vulnerable when the choices are limited. By understanding the concept of capability, the poor is not someone who has no income, but someone who cannot get out of poverty.

Determining the rights of an accused person in the defense of Iran with a chain of narrations between the sects and human rights

https://doi.org/10.22034/aeclr.2024.486367.1155

ali setarg, karam janipour

Abstract Compliance with the minimum guarantees of a fair trial is a human right. Therefore, the judicial system must provide the necessary measures to respect the rights of the accused and prevent their limitation, and provide the necessary facilities to the accused so that he can be acquitted of wrongful accusations if he is innocent. A person who is accused and violated against the principle of innocence, has the right to defend himself against this violation and accusation by using his human rights, because defense is a natural right in every respect. Defendant's defense rights are one of the most important topics of human rights and have been given serious attention in numerous human rights documents. so that limiting the defense rights of the accused is seen as a guarantee of executions; An issue that has been neglected to some extent in the internal documents of our country and in the Criminal Procedure Law of 2012 in order to reduce the limitation of the defense rights of the accused. The current research has been written with descriptive-analytical method and using library-documentary sources.

The impact of clinical criminology on the costs of criminal justice with a view to Iran's legislative criminal policy

https://doi.org/10.22034/aeclr.2024.488887.1157

zohre ghlamalizadeh, esmaeel abdollahi

Abstract Clinical criminology is one of the branches of the great science of criminology that, by having a solution and application of tools such as personality profiles, leniency institutions, amnesty, the principle of judicial separation, etc. to control the dangerous state and criminal capacity of criminals in order to prevent them from committing or repeating crimes, has a worthy and significant effect on reducing the costs of criminal justice. The findings of the research showed that clinical criminology, like a doctor, seeks to reform, treat, and prevent the criminal from repeating crimes by examining them from many angles. Therefore, the dangerous state of the individual must be recognized and subjected to criminological and social measures; in this case, the implementation of punishment or criminological and social measures can eliminate the risk of committing a crime and reduce the cost of crime. This article is descriptive in nature and describes and defines topics such as clinical criminology, criminal policy and the costs resulting from its implementation, and the impact of clinical criminological findings on the commission of crimes in order to determine the path forward. The results of the research showed that clinical criminology, by applying its special models and methods, provides significant assistance to criminal policymakers in preventing the repetition or commission of crimes, reforming offenders, and reintegrating them into society, and ultimately reducing the costs of criminal justice.

Child rights in Afghanistan law and the Convention on the Rights of the Child

Child rights in Afghanistan law and the Convention on the Rights of the Child

Volume 4, Issue 14, Autumn 2021, Pages 32-51

https://doi.org/10.22034/aeclr.2022.315580.1071

Abdulkhaliq shafaq

Abstract The child in this study is a person who has not reached the age of eighteen and is under eighteen years old.
Global efforts to protect the child as the most vulnerable member of human society led to the ratification of the 1989 Convention on the Rights of the Child and Afghanistan ratified it in 1994, preserving the "right of reservation" to all rules and regulations against Islamic law and domestic law. In addition to international efforts, Afghanistan has protected children under various domestic and international laws, including a law entitled "Protection of the Rights of the Child."
This study examines the rights of children in the laws of Afghanistan and the Convention on the Rights of the Child in a descriptive-analytical manner and concludes that in these documents, special attention has been paid to children and many rights for them from civil, cultural, economic to political are considered. .

Principle of Correctness in Worship from the Sunnis point of view

Principle of Correctness in Worship from the Sunnis point of view

Volume 2, Issue 4, Spring 2019, Pages 7-25

mohammadzaher mohammadi, mohammad roshan

Abstract Human actions are divided into three parts: worships, traditions, and habits. The religion commandments are wajeb, mustahab, Makruh, Mabah, and Haram. In this article, we are dealing with the worship subject which leads to the man's proximity to God and future life reward. Because, a charged person must know whether he can change the worship subject or not and if doubts are raised in the subject of worship, which principle should be cited in order to put the charged person out of doubt. The jurisconsults believe that the "Esalatossehhe" is applicable in transactions and habits which in this article the possibility of citation to this principle in worship from the Sunnis jurisconsults point of view will be studied. Also, different Sunnis religion disagreements over the issue of invalidity and corruption in the worship and various opinions on this issue and also types and conditions of worship and corruption-related effects in worship is discussed. Then with the citation to available sources, we will be dealing with the citation Impossibility to the "Esalatossehhe" and the Sunnis jurisconsults reasons In the field of worship. In the end, their obeyed principle in worship which is “Esalatol man” will be disputed.

Constraint procedure for doing contractual obligations  (Iranian law - Imamieh jurisprudence)

Constraint procedure for doing contractual obligations (Iranian law - Imamieh jurisprudence)

Volume 1, Issue 1, Spring 2018, Pages 7-21

hadi aghapour

Abstract abstract
The necessity of respecting the contract is to fulfill its obligations, so that failure to perform contractual obligations guarantees several performances, the most important of which is the compulsory and termination of the transaction in the legal system of Iran and Islamic jurisprudence. For example, the enforcement of the sentence or order from the court Or other law enforcement agencies that oblige the person to carry out an objective investigation of what he has undertaken, or in the event of a refusal to comply with a warrant or order, by a court with his or her legal remedies through enforcement agents or third parties, or if the obligation is committed by the person concerned With physical and financial pressures, he has to force him to fulfill his obligation The burden, which forms the most important part of the present article, is in direct and indirect fashion, and these two types of coercion are distinct according to the subject of engagement And in cases where a vested party has a direct obligation to do so, and the vendor can only demand his indemnity through indirect coercion, and if he fails to fulfill the obligation, he will be obliged to terminate the committed area, so for the importance of the matter In this article, after mentioning, we will give a general overview of the concept of commitment and types of commitment to the validity of the subject as contractual obligations, and will conclude
keyword:obligation،contracte،do،consraint

Principles and models of separation of powers in Iran and democratic political systems (Britain, France, USA)

Principles and models of separation of powers in Iran and democratic political systems (Britain, France, USA)

Volume 3, Issue 9, Autumn 2020, Pages 23-50

https://doi.org/10.22034/aeclr.2020.118097

noorbakhsk riahy

Abstract In today's world, the separation of powers as the cornerstone and cornerstone of democracy, the adornment of the constitution and the vassal of the rights and freedoms of the people and the main basis and purpose of this principle has been to achieve the original ideal of democracy. Now the question arises whether the methods and models of separation of powers in the Islamic Republic of Iran and the three political systems of the model and claimant of democracy, namely the British Parliament, the US presidency and the French semi-presidential / semi-parliamentary, really comply with the principles of separation of powers and democracy. The present study uses analytical-descriptive method to prove the hypothesis that the relationship between the principles of separation of powers and real democracy is like a link between a text and its footnote, and therefore it is not possible to choose different models of separation of powers as a brain teaser. Be clear with the basics of separation of powers and the characteristics of democracy. The result of the research will be that the above-mentioned countries have chosen different models of separation of powers based on apparent democracy, and it is suggested that because today's theory of the three powers no longer meets the demands of democracy, the fourth and popular power called "supervisory power" And subversion "should be considered in the constitutions of countries.

The financial system governing the relationship between couples in Islam and the laws of Afghanistan

The financial system governing the relationship between couples in Islam and the laws of Afghanistan

Volume 5, Issue 18, Autumn 2022, Pages 7-23

https://doi.org/10.22034/aeclr.2024.379184.1107

Abdulkhaliq shafaq

Abstract One of the most important and interesting issues in the present era is how to regulate the financial relations of couples. Due to the importance of the topic, this research has analyzed the financial system governing couple relations in Islam and Afghan laws in a descriptive-analytical way; In such a way, at first, he examined the types of financial systems governing the relations of couples and then examined the financial system governing the relations of couples in Islam and the laws of Afghanistan
The conducted investigations showed that the system of complete separation of property (financial independence of couples) is accepted in Islam. That is, each of the spouses has privileged and separate properties and having a series of conditions, he can occupy them independently and without the role of the other. There is no explicit provision in the civil law regarding the financial relations of spouses; but, the principle of financial independence of spouses has been accepted in the personal status law of Shiites, and the law on the prohibition of violence against women has also provided a guarantee for it.

A comparative study of neglect of the harmless rule in jurisprudence and criminal justice

A comparative study of neglect of the harmless rule in jurisprudence and criminal justice

Volume 4, Issue 12, Spring 2021, Pages 83-104

https://doi.org/10.22034/aeclr.2021.282207.1053

mostafa ahmadi

Abstract In legal relations, there are rules that underlie it and strengthen the foundation of justice. The no-harm rule is one of these basic rules, which is emphasized in Article 40 of the Constitution. The implication of this rule is that no one has the right to abuse their rights to the detriment of another. This rule, in addition to the Quranic, narrative and jurisprudential roots, is also based on the logic and rationality of human beings. In Western law, this rule is known as the abuse of rights, which is one of the principles restricting the freedom of individuals. In our civil and commercial laws, this rule has been mentioned many times and in different ways, and this rule is also the basis of civil liability law. But in criminal law, with the exception of a few laws that are merely verbal similarities to the rule, this issue has not been used, and this leads to many abuses by individuals. Cases such as usury and conversion of punishments and discounts and the principles of innocence and the passage of time, etc. are among the cases in which many abuses take place. The subject of this research is Iranian criminal law, which seeks to analyze and remind the relevant people in an analytical way, using library resources and work experiences.

The process of globalization and citizenship rights

The process of globalization and citizenship rights

Volume 1, Issue 3, Spring 2019, Pages 63-81

babak seifi Atashgah

Abstract Globalization is an inevitable process, which is internationalization and the elimination of geographical boundaries. The thinkers and thinkers of different countries each speak in a way about the world and there is little consensus about it. Today, globalization is the most obvious trend in the convergence of countries, the most important of which is the economic dimension. On the other hand, citizen's rights are now at the national and international level as important legal issues. Meanwhile, the Constitution of the Islamic Republic of Iran focuses on the rights of citizens and does not include differences in ethnicity, race and language in this right. In this paper, we attempt to analyze the globalization and its effects on citizenship rights, while defining the concept of globalization comprehensively, the challenges of globalization, as well as its positive and negative consequences in relation to citizenship rights. Take up The effects of globalization on citizenship rights and ways to promote citizenship rights in the age of globalization have been described and explained. The research hypothesis is that "the evidence suggests the positive impact of globalization on the citizenship rights.

Keywords Cloud